EEOC moves to dismiss transgender-discrimination lawsuits

"EEOC seeks to drop race discrimination cases brought on behalf of Black workers, citing Trump's executive order."

This is not a real headline.

But this is: "EEOC seeks to drop transgender discrimination cases, citing Trump's executive order."

What makes an accommodation "reasonable"?

Let's talk about Nguyen v. Bessent and the IRS's year-long effort to accommodate an employee with medical limitations.

Thuy-Ai Nguyen, an IT specialist at the IRS, requested multiple accommodations related to her severe depression, anxiety, and cognitive impairment. Her requests? A transfer to a different division, formal training, a part-time schedule, and the ability to work from home or transfer to a location with a shorter commute.

The IRS partially granted her requests: It offered her a new assignment with different immediate supervisors, on-the-job training, and a six-month part-time schedule. But it denied her telework request, arguing that in-person training was necessary. They also searched for positions closer to her home but found no vacancies.

Nguyen rejected the offer, arguing it wasn't a "reasonable" accommodation because her higher-level manager remained the same and she still had to commute to the same location.

The court disagreed.

WIRTW #747: the 'tariffs' edition

The Trump administration just announced new tariffs on aluminum and steel. That might not sound like a big deal to most, but for small businesses—including my beloved craft breweries—25% is a gut punch.

The craft beer industry is already struggling post-Covid. Breweries took on debt to survive the shutdowns, taproom traffic isn't what it used to be as many consumers shy away from alcohol, and supply-chain costs have been unpredictable and high. Now, just as many are trying to regain their footing, they get hit with another hurdle.

Most craft breweries package their beer in aluminum cans. If the cost of aluminum goes up because of tariffs, so does the cost of packaging. And it's not just cans, brewing equipment is made of steel. Fermenters, brite tanks, brewhouses, kegs, construction materials—all of it. So, breweries that want to replace aging equipment, expand, or just keep up with demand are looking at higher costs across the board.

And let's be clear: These costs don't just disappear. Breweries will have to pass them down to consumers. That means your favorite local beer is about to get more expensive. Meanwhile, the biggest players—macro-breweries with deep pockets—can absorb these price increases far more easily than your neighborhood local. This isn't just an economic issue; it's a competition killer.

Tariffs like these don't "protect American businesses." They protect big business at the expense of the little guys who drive innovation, create jobs, and bring character to our communities. If we want to support small businesses, we should be fighting against policies that make it harder for them to compete.

---

Here's what I read this week that you should read, too.

The attack on DEI does not mean employers must or should eliminate anti-harassment training

Even as some push back forcefully against DEI workplace initiatives, courts are pushing back even harder. Consider these excerpts from Diemert v. City of Seattle, in which a federal judge dismissed the claims of a white man who alleged that his employer's mandatory DEI training created a racially hostile work environment.

Protecting the rule of law

"Judges aren't allowed to control the executive's legitimate power." — Vice President JD Vance

We need to talk about the rule of law—because it's under serious attack.

How to respond to the Justice Department's DEI hitlist

"The Department of Justice's Civil Rights Division will investigate, eliminate, and penalize illegal DEI and DEIA preferences, mandates, policies, programs, and activities in the private sector." 

 

That's the key sentence from a Feb. 5, 2025, memo that Attorney General Pam Bondi sent to all DOJ employees.

What does it mean? No one really knows. What we do know is that diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility are top priorities for this administration. The key question is how the administration defines "illegal."

Here's what we can infer so far:

WIRTW #746: the 'fly, eagles fly' edition

All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Are you ready for the Big Game? As a Philly native and die-hard Eagles fan, I sure am! 

Here's the official Ohio Employer Law Blog prediction for Sunday. Eagles 31 - Chiefs 27. Book it. Hurts, Barkley, et al., deny Reid, Mahomes, and Kelce their threepeat. Saquon runs for 165 and 2 touchdowns. Hurts throws for 200 and touchdown, and tush pushes his way for another. Brandon Graham returns from injury to score a key sack. And rookie phenom Quinyon Mitchell seals the win with a last minute interception. At least that's my dream scenario (other than a stress-free blowout).

---

Also, please check out the latest episode of The Norah and Dad Show. Norah and I discuss her 2nd semester of college, her classes, and her recent biliteracy certification. We also discuss our recent naming to the list of the best dad and daughter podcasts. 

You'll find the episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, Amazon Music, Overcast, the web, and anywhere else you get your podcasts. 

---

Here's what I read this week that you should read, too.

What the EEOC just said—and didn't say—about the current state of workplace right

"The EEOC is open for business." That's what the agency just declared in a series of frequently asked questions about the impact of Trump's Executive Orders on its operations and the laws it enforces.

The FAQs acknowledge the agency's lack of a quorum and its resulting inability to issue or rescind guidance or policy statements. They also affirm that the EEOC continues to accept and process discrimination charges, conduct investigations, issue right-to-sue letters, and litigate cases.

What hiring and employment look like without DEI

What does a country without DEI look like? Some people say that's what they want. No more diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives in hiring or the workplace. Just a pure "meritocracy."

So what does that actually look like?

The dos and don't of workplace AI policies

According to a recent BBC article, half of all workers use personal generative AI tools (like ChatGPT) at work—often without their employer's knowledge or permission. So the question isn't whether your employees are using AI—it's how to ensure they use it responsibly.

A well-crafted AI policy can help your business leverage AI's benefits while avoiding the legal, ethical, and operational risks that come with it. Here's a simple framework to help guide your workplace AI strategy:

We cannot simply oblish OSHA

"The Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 repealed. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration is abolished."

That's the full text of H.R. 86 — the Nullify Occupational Safety and Health Administration Act — with Representative Andy Biggs introduced in Congress late last week.

In support of his reckless and dangerous legislation, Biggs stated:

"OSHA's existence is yet another example of the federal government creating agencies to address issues that are more appropriately handled by state governments and private employers.… It's time that we fight back against the bloated federal government and eliminate agencies that never should have been established in the first place."

WIRTW #745: the 'biliterate' edition

Until this week, I thought being bilingual meant fluency in a second language—the ability to read, write, listen, and speak with ease. I was wrong. Someone who can do all of those things in two languages is actually biliterate. Being bilingual, on the other hand, simply means having the ability to speak in two languages.

I learned this distinction when the Ohio Wesleyan University Department of World Languages and Cultures certified my daughter as biliterate in French.

From the school's press release:

"Ohio Wesleyan University language students are now able to earn the Global Seal of Biliteracy, an internationally recognized micro-credential that enables them to verify their linguistic abilities when applying for jobs or graduate school. The university's Department of World Languages and Cultures began utilizing the third-party assessment this fall, with 19 students earning the 'functional fluency' biliteracy seal at the end of the semester. Andrea Colvin, Ph.D., chair of World Languages and Cultures, said students' earning the Global Seal of Biliteracy is 'a testament to their hard work, dedication, and passion for language learning.'"

Norah was one of eight students credentialed as biliterate in French. I don't know how many of those eight were also first-semester freshmen, but to be fair, she had 13 years of French education before starting college. All American schools should begin foreign language instruction in kindergarten—it's one of the greatest shortcomings of our education system.

Félicitations, Norah! Needless to say, I'm a very proud dad.

---

Here's what I read this week that you should read, too.

Microagressions as an adverse action

A "microaggression" is a subtle, often unintentional comment or action that conveys bias or discrimination against a marginalized group. For example, asking a person of color, "How did you get this job?" telling a colleague with an accent, "Your English is so good," or scheduling team-building activities at bars, knowing some employees don't drink for religious reasons.

In the right circumstances, however, microaggressions can also amount to an adverse action that supports a workplace retaliation claim.

Consider the recent case of Uchitel v. Solid Waste Services. 

Trump illegally guts the EEOC of its Democratic members

Remember last week when I told you that Trump would try to dismantle all of our federal workplace discrimination laws?

Well, the first shoe has just dropped—right on the EEOC’s neck.

Late yesterday, news broke that Trump fired two Democratic EEOC Commissioners, Jocelyn Samuels and Charlotte Burrows. This move leaves only two Commissioners on the five-member EEOC: Republican Andrea Lucas (whom Trump had previously named acting chair) and Democrat Kalpana Kotagal and no quorum. Without a quorum, the EEOC is now paralyzed—unable to issue rules, provide legal guidance, or direct staff to take key enforcement actions like pursuing litigation.

Missing time sheets doom employee's overtime claim

One of the most challenging tasks is proving a negative. Yet, this is precisely the problem employers face when defending wage-and-hour cases in which employees allege off-the-clock work. The employer argues that time records define the boundaries of the paid workday, while the employee contends they should be compensated for work performed outside of those clock-ins and clock-outs.

For example, consider Osborne v. JAB Management Services, a case recently decided by the 7th Circuit. Tara Osborne worked remotely as a technical support specialist for JAB, providing on-call support to its customers. As a salaried remote worker, she had the flexibility to design her own schedule. While she did not track any time worked over 40 hours per week, Osborne claimed she worked an average of 10 hours per day and 15 hours of overtime per week, including weekends.

The 7th Circuit affirmed the trial court's dismissal of Osborne's lawsuit for unpaid overtime. 

Taking from your employees' tip pool? It's illegal

It’s Dry January, and brewery owners are feeling the pinch. You might be tempted to supplement your income by dipping into your employees’ tip pool. That would be a huge mistake. It isn’t just bad form to take your employees’ hard-earned tips. It’s also illegal.

Under the FLSA, owners, managers, and supervisors are strictly forbidden from taking any part of pooled tips. There are no excuses.

Is Trump coming after Title VII next?

"Dad, did Trump just get rid of workplace discrimination laws?" That's the question my daughter asked me yesterday.

She was referring to his Executive Order entitled, Ending Illegal Discrimination and Restoring Merit Based Opportunity.

To answer Norah's question, no, that EO did not get rid of workplace discrimination laws. Instead, it dismantled federal Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion programs and placed all federal DEI employees on unpaid leave. It also rescinded Executive Order 11246, originally signed by President Lyndon Johnson in 1965, which prohibited federal contractors from discriminating based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin, and further removing their affirmative action obligations in that regard.

WIRTW #744: the 'London Calling … the podcast' edition

In the latest episode of The Norah and Dad Show, we recap our family Christmas holiday to London. Here are links to everything we mention in the episode. 

• Hux Hotel
• Peter Pan Cup
• The Beatles Magical Mystery Walking Tour
• Third Man Records
• Arsenal Tickets
• Afternoon Tea at the Goring
• Atticus Blue (Leicester Square busker)
  
• Hawksmoor Seven Dials
• The Original Ted Lasso Tour
• Reale Camiceria (the "unofficial" Ted Lasso store)
• The Prince's Head Pub
• Camden Market 
  

You'll find the episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, Amazon Music, Overcast, the web, and anywhere else you get your podcasts. 

---

Here's what I read this week that you should read, too.

Neurodivergence is not an excuse for racism

"He's on the spectrum" is not an excuse for racism.

I've seen more than one person attempt to justify Elon Musk's Nazi salute, or dismiss it, citing his Asperger's syndrome, a form of autism spectrum disorder.

I call 🐂💩!

Bigotry, racism, and antisemitism are not symptoms of Asperger's or autism. They are, however, hallmarks of being a bigot, racist, or antisemite.

A lesson on ADA compliance

What happens when an employer fails to take an employee's disability seriously? It might look a lot like the case of Sutherland v. Peterson's Oil Service.

This recent First Circuit decision offers a crash course on the perils of ignoring an employee's requests for accommodations—and the consequences of getting it wrong.