The EEOC says he had a case. The calendar says he didn't.
The EEOC found reasonable cause to believe the City of Detroit denied a police officer a reasonable accommodation and forced him to retire.
Why, then, did Plaintiff William Woods lose his federal ADA lawsuit? His EEOC charge was 22 days late.
Woods, a Detroit police officer, worked restricted duty after a back re-injury. In December 2017, the department applied to retire him on non-duty disability. Woods says the department was pushing him out instead of accommodating him. He applied for duty disability instead. On April 5, 2018, the pension board approved his duty disability application at a hearing. Woods then retired on April 30.
He filed his EEOC charge on February 21, 2019, claiming that on April 30 he was suddenly denied his restricted-duty accommodation and involuntarily retired. In January 2023, the EEOC issued its cause finding. That's an agency finding, not a ruling on the merits.
The Sixth Circuit affirmed summary judgment for the City without ever reaching the merits. The claim died on timeliness.
The clock was the whole case. Woods had 300 days to file his EEOC charge. The issue was when that clock started running. He argued it started on his last day of work. The court disagreed. The period starts when the employer makes and communicates a final decision, not when the paycheck stops. Mere continuity of employment doesn't extend it.
Day one was April 5. Day 300 was January 30, 2019. His charge came 22 days too late.
Equitable tolling—a doctrine that allows a court to pause a deadline when someone diligently pursues a claim but an extraordinary circumstance beyond their control prevents them from filing on time—can save a late filing. It didn't save Woods here. He pointed to a brain injury, severe depression, anxiety, and PTSD.
The court said that wasn't enough to show a specific circumstance beyond his control that kept him from filing on time. He also offered no evidence of diligence, which the court called "essentially fatal."
There are three solid lessons here for employers.
1. Nail down the date a decision was communicated. The City won because Woods' own deposition put him in the room on April 5. Develop the record in discovery.
2. Plead timeliness and exhaustion in your answer. Every single time as long as you have a good faith basis to do so.
3. Don't treat a cause finding as the end of the story. The court never reached the merits. It didn't have to.
Deadlines don't care how strong the claim is.
(1).png)