No contract, no coffee: why winning the union election is the easy part for employees
Cleveland City Council voted unanimously on Monday to boycott Starbucks until the company reaches a contract with its unionized baristas.
The first Starbucks store voted to unionize in Buffalo in December 2021. Nearly five years later, more than 12,000 baristas at over 700 stores still don't have a first contract
Starbucks says the union walked away from the table. The union says Starbucks stonewalled. I'm not refereeing that. The lesson for employers and employees is the same either way: organizing is the easy part; bargaining is the hard part
Employees vote. The NLRB certifies the union. The employer has to bargain. But the National Labor Relations Act only requires good-faith bargaining, not agreement. Further, the Supreme Court has held that the Board can't force either side to accept a contract term.
That leaves a lot of leverage with the employer.
Economically, the employer keeps the doors open and the paychecks flowing while employees decide whether to give theirs up. Strikers lose wages. Economic strikers can be permanently replaced. And with about 17,000 U.S. cafes, Starbucks can absorb a walkout at its union stores. The other cafes keep pouring.
Legally, an employer can bargain hard, say no, and hold its position. After a genuine impasse, it can implement its last offer or lock out. A year after certification, employees can file a decertification petition if there's still no contract.
Small employers, read that economic point carefully. Starbucks can absorb a strike. A 12-person manufacturer or restaurant often can't. When the strikers are a third of your staff, replacing them and keeping customers is far harder. Your legal leverage is the same: you never have to agree to terms the business can't afford. Your economic leverage is thinner. And if you say you can't afford it, expect the union to ask to see the books
There's a limit. Surface bargaining is an unfair labor practice. So is retaliating against organizers. Cross that line and the leverage shifts, along with the remedies.
Employees aren't powerless. Their leverage just isn't at the table. It's public pressure: strikes timed for Red Cup Day, boycotts, and city council resolutions. None of those is a contract. Pressure takes time, and time favors the side that isn't missing paychecks.
So here's what employers who don't want a union need to keep front of mind. Fight the organizing campaign with every legal tool you have. You're entitled to. But if you lose the election, don't assume the world is ending, and don't panic.
The election is the beginning of the process. It's not the end of your business. And it's not the finish line for the union, either.
(1).png)